Lesson #9: How The Broader Economic Environment Structures Your Trades
Let’s start this one off by correcting a misconception: Bitcoin is not a safe haven asset yet. When the stock market falls, Bitcoin falls too (and more). Below, Bitcoin is in black, and the S&P 500 is in blue.
The reason is that everyone needed money and pulled from all the sources they had. At some point, Bitcoin might prove to be a safe haven asset, like gold, but it isn’t there yet. (And, incidentally, gold sold off with the market in March too.)
The big picture here is Lesson #9: the broader economic environment will drive bubbles and crashes.
If that environment is in good or neutral shape, then you can invest in Bitcoin and other bubbly assets, like marijuana stocks or electric vehicles. If it turns aggressively negative, then you need to stop all bubble hunting.
To make this insight actionable for trading, we can start with a metaphor: trading is structured in layers of dependence like a pyramid. To schematize that, it helps to think of this pyramid as having five layers.
Five Layers of Dependence
The following image gives you an idea of how the more basic layers of the pyramid structure the later layers of the pyramid.
Layer #1: The Basic Economic Cycle
The base layer, even still for the entire world, is the US economy. Apart from events like pandemics, it rises and falls based on a credit cycle. You should really watch Ray Dalio’s video about the credit cycle and the economy, but I can explain the key points you’ll need for trading.
Basically, people borrow money for a variety of reasons. Dalio cites greed, but I think businesses have to borrow to get more money to work with to beat out their competition.
In any case, if a few people default, banks are fine. If a lot of people do, then the status of all the other loans is put in jeopardy. Since a lot of the world’s money is actually credit (to banks), when too many people default, banks begin to default, and then the world’s economy spirals downwards.
So if the basic economic cycle is not well, then almost nothing is well.
Layer #2: Industry Cycles
Built on top of that basic credit cycle, you have industry cycles. Oil, for example, was terrible from 2014 to 2017, then began to bounce back in late 2018 only to be hit with the COVID pandemic. It didn’t matter which company you picked, they all got slaughtered. Here’s a picture of ExxonMobile ($XOM), one of the world’s largest companies and the contemporary heir of Standard Oil, which made Rockefeller rich.
Over the past five years, you can see how the oil downturn crushed XOM. While the S&P 500 gained just over 100% during that period, XOM lost just over 38%. You’ll also notice how the decline in the basic layer, proxied by the S&P 500 here, led to a massive decline in XOM too.
So in addition to the basic economic cycle, your specific industry cycle has to be good too.
Layers # 3 and #4: Individual Companies and Coins
If an industry is doing well, then individual members (whether coins or stocks) in that industry can do well. Here’s a dramatic example with an offshore driller, Transocean ($RIG), and the price of oil as indicated by the $USO. Oil is in blue, $RIG is in black.
It was a wild ride for $RIG, but as soon as oil began to turn around, the price of $RIG began to climb dramatically–up from $.94 to $3.49 presently.
A point of clarification might help here. In the pyramid image, I had two layers devoted to industry stocks and coins. The reason is that there is an enormous difference between $XOM, which was never in danger of going out of business, and $RIG which might still go out of business. So while $XOM’s price recovery turns on its industry health, it’s not in the same category as $RIG, which needs a prolonged oil price recovery to avoid bankruptcy.
I would put $XOM in layer 3, then, and $RIG in layer 4.
Layer #5: Levered Products
At the highest level, the 5th indicated in the pyramid, you’ll find levered products. Those are securities like call options, 3x levered funds, and speculative alt-coins that depend on the price appreciation of other altcoins. Those will make a ton more money than the underlying securities … and will lose a ton more money if things turn out poorly.
Here’s an image of the UPRO (=3x the S&P) in the recovery of the S&P 500 since March. It’s almost a 300% return!
…and here’s an image of its decline into March (ouch!)
That’s a 61% decline from the starting point 10 months earlier. From its height, the UPRO went from $81 to $18.63 for a 77% decline in a month!
The fifth layer goes up a lot then … and down too. You need to make sure that everything else is healthy if you’re going to look at these sorts of trades.
How To Apply This
The most obvious way to apply this lesson is to understand that when you are picking bubbles for trading, you need to go through a sort of checklist.
- Ask first: is the basic economic cycle healthy?
- Next ask: is the industry I’m looking to trade healthy?
- Then ask: how am I planning to position myself in that industry? With a layer-3 type company? With a layer-4 type company? Or with a layer-5 leveraged product?
If you are picking a layer-3 type company, then you’ll be pretty ok with bumpiness in the basic economic cycle and even the industry cycle. If you’re picking a leveraged product (layer-5), then you need a really fast responding strategy to protect you against downside risk.
But how can I tell whether or not the industry is healthy?
I have been giving you the tools to figure out how to find your own industry-level indicators since Lesson #2. Basically, the Simple Moving Average of the last 200 days (SMA 200) does a good job of telling you whether an industry is ok.
- In oil, for example, you could just pull up the SMA 200 on the $USO.
- With cryptocurrencies, you could use the SMA 200 on Bitcoin itself.
- In the electric vehicle market, you could use the SMA 200 on $TSLA.
- For marijuana stocks, the matter is a little more complicated. You’ll have to rely primarily on the political news coming from Washington DC concerning national legalization and decriminalization.
In Lesson #3 I told you all about how to use the ROC14 (Rate of Price Change over the last 14 days) to pick out some better exit points, and I warned you about relying too heavily on that. In future pieces, I’ll go over some of the methods that I use to get a little better insight into these indicators, but these basics will make money.
How can I tell whether the basic economic cycle is healthy?
Your biggest difficulty is going to come from trying to construct your own basic economic cycle indicator. I will absolutely teach you how to do this, as that’s the whole point of my newsletter.
I’ll also note up front there are three problems that we’ll have to tackle:
- it will take some time,
- some of you won’t want to go through all the effort,
- it takes an investment in a data provider to get you the information you need to build your algorithms.
That third one will cost you about $200 / month — but it can be absolutely worth it (I do it and have done it for years!).
For the present, I’ve decided to put together a simple subscription product. I’ll give it away to you all for free for a bit. It’ll be my Weekly Watch for Bubbles. This will tell you:
- whether the basic economic cycle is intact using my own 10-signal, 2-layer proprietary algorithm with a testable history,
- whether an industry cycle is intact for Bitcoin, Oil Markets, EV Markets, and Marijuana Markets,
- and the actual positions that I own and when I initiated my trades for these bubbly areas.
I’ll explain more in the next lesson. But right now, you won’t have to pay anything at all. Also, the lessons in trading bubbles and real-time notices will continue to be free. I’ll only be offering something new if you want it.
Finally, it will be cheap.
How much would you be willing to pay to have a reliable indicator for when to start a trade? How about when to get out of a trade and save yourself from losses? Would it be worth $9 a month to you?
So that’s it for this week, but be on the look-out for the Weekly Bubble!
General financial disclaimer: This post is provided for entertainment purposes only. I am not giving you financial advice and I am not a financial advisor. You should expect no financial returns one way or another based on my statements. These points hold equally for any statements that could be attributed to The Art of The Bubble or any related business entities. If you decide to buy or invest in anything, then your returns and potential losses are your own. No statements about taxation are taxable advice and you are encouraged to consult your own tax professional. You are also encouraged to do your own due diligence before investing in anything